Parshat Vayeitzei: When Love Cannot Change What Hurts
Finding the Strength to Remain Present When We Cannot Take Away Another Person’s Pain
Introduction
Love carries with it a natural desire to protect those closest to us from suffering. When someone we care about is in pain, our instinct is to search for something that might bring relief, whether through reassurance, guidance, practical assistance, or finding the right words. We want our concern to make a difference, and discovering that our efforts have brought little relief can be difficult to accept. The depth of our love can make this helplessness particularly unsettling.
The experience becomes more complicated when we recognize how little influence we may have over another person's circumstances. As the suffering continues, we may struggle to determine whether there is something more we should be doing or whether we have reached the limits of what we can reasonably offer. The uncertainty can leave us questioning our judgment, particularly when the person who is struggling continues to look toward us for help.
The frustration of being unable to help can gradually influence the way we respond. We may become impatient, offer explanations that provide little comfort, or withdraw from conversations that leave us feeling inadequate. Our concern for the person who is suffering becomes entangled with our own disappointment and emotional exhaustion, making it harder to respond with the sensitivity and patience we would otherwise wish to offer.
The deeper challenge concerns what happens within a relationship when our desire to help repeatedly meets with disappointment. How do we understand our responsibilities when we cannot provide the relief someone needs, and how might our own feelings of helplessness influence the way we respond to their pain?
I. A Promise in the Midst of Uncertainty
Yaakov's departure from Be'er Sheva marks a profound turning point in his life. Until now, he has lived in the home of Yitzchak and Rivka, surrounded by the familiar structure of his family and the spiritual inheritance of Avraham. Carrying his father's blessing, he leaves that world behind after the conflict with Esav, whose anger has made remaining at home dangerous. Rivka has directed him toward her brother Lavan, but Yaakov cannot know how he will be received or when he might return. The Torah introduces this transition with the words וַיֵּצֵא יַעֲקֹב מִבְּאֵר שָׁבַע וַיֵּלֶךְ חָרָנָה (Bereishit 28:10), beginning a journey that will demand far more from him than he could have anticipated.
As Yaakov travels, he stops for the night because the sun has set, taking stones from the surrounding area and placing them near his head before lying down to sleep. Far from the security of his parents' home, he dreams of a ladder extending from the earth toward heaven, with angels ascending and descending upon it. Rashi (28:12) explains that the ascending angels had accompanied Yaakov within Eretz Yisrael and were now being replaced by angels designated to accompany him outside the Land. The angels who have accompanied him until this point do not continue beyond the boundaries of Eretz Yisrael, but their departure does not leave him unprotected. The care appropriate to one stage of his life gives way to Divine protection suited to the unfamiliar circumstances awaiting him.
Ramban (28:12) develops a broader understanding of the dream, interpreting the ladder as a representation of Divine providence and the relationship between heavenly direction and events unfolding in the world below. The angels ascend and descend in fulfillment of the missions entrusted to them, while Hashem stands above the ladder as the ultimate source of their authority. The vision presents a world in which events that appear disconnected from an earthly perspective are governed by Divine direction, even when their significance lies beyond human understanding. Ramban then emphasizes the personal meaning of Hashem standing above the ladder and addressing Yaakov directly. Beyond the general framework of providence represented by the angels, Yaakov receives an assurance from Hashem Himself concerning the journey ahead.
That assurance is expressed in deeply personal language when Hashem tells Yaakov, וְהִנֵּה אָנֹכִי עִמָּךְ וּשְׁמַרְתִּיךָ בְּכֹל אֲשֶׁר־תֵּלֵךְ וַהֲשִׁבֹתִיךָ אֶל־הָאֲדָמָה הַזֹּאת כִּי לֹא אֶעֱזָבְךָ (28:15). Rashi explains that the promise of protection addresses Yaakov's fear of Esav and Lavan, the dangers he has reason to anticipate as he leaves his father's home. Hashem assures him that he will be guarded throughout his travels and eventually returned to the land. The words אָנֹכִי עִמָּךְ establish a personal commitment, accompanied by specific promises concerning Yaakov's safety and future. Yaakov has been given a foundation upon which to proceed, without knowing the difficulties, decisions, and experiences that will shape the years ahead.
His response to the revelation reflects the practical concerns accompanying him as he begins this new chapter of life. After awakening, Yaakov establishes a monument and makes a vow, declaring אִם־יִהְיֶה אֱלֹהִים עִמָּדִי וּשְׁמָרַנִי בַּדֶּרֶךְ הַזֶּה אֲשֶׁר אָנֹכִי הוֹלֵךְ וְנָתַן־לִי לֶחֶם לֶאֱכֹל וּבֶגֶד לִלְבֹּשׁ (28:20). Rashi understands Yaakov's words as referring back to the commitments he has received, expressing his desire that they be fulfilled. His request for bread, clothing, and protection brings the extraordinary revelation into the ordinary realities of human existence. Although he has encountered a vision connecting heaven and earth and heard Hashem's assurance concerning his future, he must still travel, sustain himself, and establish his place in an unfamiliar household.
The years that follow reveal the complexity of that journey. Yaakov encounters Lavan's deception, experiences complications within his marriages, and labors for years under demanding conditions before confronting the dangers involved in leaving Lavan's household. These experiences unfold within the very journey for which Hashem has promised His protection, touching his livelihood, family relationships, and hopes for the future. The Torah does not present Divine protection as freedom from every hardship, nor does it suggest that the difficulties he encounters undermine the promise he received.
Among those struggles is the anguish of someone Yaakov deeply loves. At Beit El, Hashem had promised to accompany him throughout his journey, offering assurances that only Divine power could fulfill. Within his marriage to Rachel, Yaakov encounters a different kind of difficulty, arising from another person's suffering and the expectations it places upon those closest to her. Their exchange brings the relationship between love, responsibility, and human limitations into sharper focus.
II. When Another Person's Pain Becomes Our Helplessness
Rachel, the woman for whom Yaakov willingly worked seven years and whose love the Torah explicitly emphasizes, remains unable to bear children while Leah gives birth to four sons. Within a household already complicated by the circumstances of Yaakov's marriages, her longing for children becomes increasingly difficult to bear. The Torah describes her jealousy of Leah before recording her appeal to her husband: הָבָה־לִּי בָנִים וְאִם־אַיִן מֵתָה אָנֹכִי (Bereishit 30:1). Rashi, drawing upon the teaching that a person without children is considered as though dead, conveys the severity of her distress. He also interprets Rachel's jealousy as directed toward Leah's righteousness, suggesting that she believes her sister has merited children through spiritual qualities she herself longs to attain. She turns in desperation to the husband whose love she knows, hoping he can provide the help she so urgently needs.
Yaakov's reaction is immediate and forceful. The Torah records וַיִּחַר־אַף יַעֲקֹב בְּרָחֵל וַיֹּאמֶר הֲתַחַת אֱלֹהִים אָנֹכִי אֲשֶׁר־מָנַע מִמֵּךְ פְּרִי־בָטֶן (30:2). Radak understands his anger as an objection to Rachel's apparent attribution of Divine power to him. The granting of children belongs to Hashem, and no human being can independently determine such an outcome. According to Radak, had she asked Yaakov to pray for Divine mercy, her request would have been appropriate. His interpretation establishes a genuine limitation upon what Yaakov can accomplish, regardless of how deeply he loves his wife.
Rashi, drawing upon Bereishit Rabbah, presents a different understanding of Rachel's appeal. She expects Yaakov to pray on her behalf, just as Yitzchak prayed for Rivka when she was unable to conceive. Yaakov distinguishes his circumstances from those of his father: Yitzchak had no children, whereas he already has sons through Leah. Rashi concludes with the words מִמֵּךְ מָנַע וְלֹא מִמֶּנִּי — Hashem has withheld children from you, not from me. The distinction exposes the emotional distance that can emerge when one person's suffering is experienced differently by someone who loves them. Although they share a marriage, Rachel's childlessness is not something Yaakov experiences in the same way.
Ramban examines the exchange with particular attention to Yaakov's anger, questioning why he should answer so sharply when righteous individuals regularly pray on behalf of others, including people with whom they have no personal relationship. Rachel's suffering should certainly be worthy of her husband's prayers. Ramban explains that she was asking Yaakov to continue praying until she received children, believing that his love for her and his closeness to Hashem should enable him to secure the outcome she sought. Her expectation therefore extended beyond requesting his prayers; she wanted a result that even sincere and persistent supplication could not guarantee. Ramban also raises the possibility that Yaakov had already prayed for Rachel without receiving the answer they desired. If so, her appeal confronted him with the frustration of having already sought Divine mercy while remaining unable to relieve the suffering of someone he loved.
Bereishit Rabbah (71:7) introduces a challenge that cannot be dismissed by explaining the limits of Yaakov's ability. The Midrash records Hashem's response to the way he answered Rachel: כָּךְ עוֹנִין אֶת הַמְּעוּקוֹת — is this how one responds to those in distress? Its criticism concerns the manner in which Yaakov addressed someone already overwhelmed by anguish, rather than suggesting that he possessed the power to grant her children. Ramban cites this Midrash within his discussion of Yaakov's anger, leaving us to consider the tension between the legitimacy of his limitations and the sensitivity Rachel's suffering required. Even when another person's expectations exceed what we can reasonably provide, the distress underlying those expectations remains real.
Rachel's anguish continues following this exchange, and Rashi's explanation of her next words reveals that the conversation between husband and wife has not ended. She reminds Yaakov that Avraham prayed on behalf of Sarah despite already having a child through Hagar. When Yaakov points out that Sarah had brought Hagar into her household, Rachel offers Bilhah, declaring וְאִבָּנֶה גַם אָנֹכִי מִמֶּנָּה (30:3). Her decision follows Sarah's precedent while reflecting her determination to pursue another possibility. The narrative proceeds through the births of children to the other women in Yaakov's household before returning to Rachel herself. Only later does the Torah declare וַיִּזְכֹּר אֱלֹהִים אֶת־רָחֵל וַיִּשְׁמַע אֵלֶיהָ אֱלֹהִים וַיִּפְתַּח אֶת־רַחְמָהּ (30:22). Ramban connects this Divine response to Rachel's own prayers, emphasizing her appeal to Hashem.
The contrast with Yaakov's earlier experience at Beit El now comes into focus. Hashem had assured him, וְהִנֵּה אָנֹכִי עִמָּךְ — I am with you (28:15). When Rachel turns to Yaakov in her anguish, his response begins הֲתַחַת אֱלֹהִים אָנֹכִי — am I in the place of God? (30:2). The repeated אָנֹכִי invites us to consider what Yaakov could not offer Rachel, and what he still could.
III. When Our Helplessness Shapes Our Response
Those who love someone experiencing mental illness may invest considerable effort in arranging professional care, seeking guidance, offering reassurance, and adjusting family routines. A parent may struggle to understand why a child continues to find attending school or participating in family life overwhelming despite receiving substantial support. A spouse may repeatedly offer comfort to a partner experiencing depression, only to discover that love and encouragement cannot penetrate the depth of their despair. When improvement does not follow, loved ones may question whether they have misunderstood the suffering, overlooked something important, or reached the limits of what they can provide.
There is a particular helplessness in knowing that someone we love is suffering while recognizing that we cannot fully enter their experience. A person struggling with severe anxiety may understand intellectually that a feared situation presents little objective danger while remaining overwhelmed by the prospect of facing it. Someone experiencing depression may recognize that they are loved without having the emotional strength to respond to that affection or participate in relationships that once brought meaning to their life. What appears as unwillingness, indifference, or resistance may reflect distress that the individual cannot easily explain. Those closest to them may offer the reassurance they themselves would have wanted, only to discover that it provides little comfort.
As these experiences accumulate, loved ones may begin interpreting familiar behaviors differently. A family member who has spent months encouraging someone experiencing depression may perceive continued withdrawal as personal rejection. Repeated reassurance offered to someone with severe anxiety may give way to impatience when the same fears return. Conversations once motivated by concern can become burdened by expectations of improvement, leaving the person in distress feeling misunderstood or responsible for the disappointment of those trying to help. Meanwhile, family members may grow discouraged by their inability to make a difference, even as their concern remains genuine. The emotional distance that develops can be especially painful because neither fully understands what the other is carrying.
Yaakov and Rachel's exchange speaks directly to this experience. Although Rachel's anguish is not a psychiatric condition, her appeal to Yaakov illuminates the difficulty of responding to suffering we cannot relieve. Rashi records Yaakov's distinction, מִמֵּךְ מָנַע וְלֹא מִמֶּנִּי — Hashem has withheld children from you, not from me. His words identify a genuine difference between their circumstances, but the Midrash's question, כָּךְ עוֹנִין אֶת הַמְּעוּקוֹת, asks us to consider how such an explanation is received by someone overwhelmed by pain. Within families confronting mental illness, statements such as "I've done everything I can," "It's beyond my control," or "You have to want to get better" may express genuine frustration or contain an element of truth. They can also leave the person who is struggling feeling that their suffering has become theirs to carry alone. Recognizing what lies beyond our ability does not settle how we should speak to someone who is suffering.
Living alongside serious psychological suffering also carries burdens that extend beyond the immediate moments of distress. Family routines may be disrupted, treatment decisions can become sources of continuing uncertainty, and parents, spouses, or siblings may grieve changes in relationships that once felt familiar. Such circumstances can diminish patience and emotional resilience without diminishing love or commitment. Those providing support may themselves need understanding, guidance, and opportunities to express their fears without feeling that acknowledging their own struggles takes anything away from the person they are trying to help.
When suffering continues despite sincere efforts to help, even ordinary expressions of care can begin to feel inadequate. A conversation, a reassuring word, or time spent together may appear insignificant beside the depth of another person's distress. Their meaning, however, need not depend upon producing an immediate change. Listening without demanding an explanation, acknowledging pain without rushing to correct it, and maintaining contact when someone has withdrawn can preserve connection during periods of uncertainty. Appropriate treatment and practical assistance remain essential, but the value of these quieter expressions of concern cannot always be measured by visible improvement. They allow a relationship to continue offering care and belonging even when neither person knows what the future will bring.
Conclusion
At Beit El, Hashem promises Yaakov וְהִנֵּה אָנֹכִי עִמָּךְ, assuring him of His presence throughout the uncertain journey ahead. That promise does not spare Yaakov the hardships he will encounter, nor do those hardships diminish the assurance he has received. Years later, when Rachel turns to him in anguish, Yaakov responds הֲתַחַת אֱלֹהִים אָנֹכִי, acknowledging that he cannot accomplish what belongs to Hashem alone. The contrast between these two expressions of אָנֹכִי brings into focus the difference between Divine assurance and the limitations of human love. We cannot offer another person the certainty of Hashem's protection, but the Midrash challenges us to consider what our own presence can mean when we cannot remove their suffering.
Those who are struggling with mental illness may continue to need the love of family and friends even when they cannot express appreciation, accept reassurance, or participate in relationships as they once did. Their inability to respond as we hope does not diminish the significance of remaining emotionally available, although doing so may require considerable strength and support from those around us.
The challenge is to recognize what lies beyond our ability without allowing that recognition to become emotional distance. Yaakov's words remind us that we cannot assume responsibility for outcomes that are not ours to determine, while the Midrash calls us to attend to how we respond to those whose suffering continues. We may never fully understand another person's pain or possess the means to relieve it, but we can remain mindful of how our helplessness influences the way we speak, listen, and respond. Love cannot always change what hurts, but its significance does not end where its ability to bring relief reaches its limits.
Have a Wonderful Shabbos!!!
Yaakov Lazar






Comments